Monday, July 11, 2011

Letter to G - Literary / Narrative Journalism

Dear G,

I said I'd write soon and then fell into a listless spell - the kind in which you get a fair bit of work done and all of it is more or less inspired and interesting, but nothing compared to that delicious internal universe you reside in with your ideas, your words and the creative creatures you will make out of them.

So, I've not been able, nor willing, to write.

I did read something that reminded me of why I write and what kind of writing, ultimately, I sort of fantasize about being able to do really well. The birth of this kind of writing is captured here in the New York Magazine by one of its great proponents, Tom Wolfe. I'm talking about literary journalism. Trust me to fantasize about the one kind of writing that is improbable and impossible in an authoritarian city-state in which there is no free press. But perhaps that is what makes it all the more delectable - ah pursuit of the impossible.

This love affair began a while ago though. I think hints of it began when I was in university, actually. When I was able to take literary liberties (narrative structures that are interesting; subtle flourishes) in essays about cinema, literature or even cultural theory and philosophy, I first sensed it. But academic writing nearly killed it as much as I enjoyed theory and theorizing. Having to stop and substantiate, footnote, supplement, provide citations and references to other instances in which your idea was raised, expressed and written about at another time, foreshadowing the development of said idea etc.etc. etc. ad nauseum made me realize academic writing was intensely crippling. It felt like wearing armour, a cumbersome, heavy and movement-restriction suit to lumber about on the surface of the moon, when really all you want to do is fly off the surface and defy gravity.

I knew I'd never do a PhD once I was reminded by M that the only thing drawing me to it was a love of philosophy, theory and primarily, a love of writing. And so one day, he put it simply. He said, "If you love writing, then write! Don't do a PhD. It will ruin and curtail that ability and that freedom." I listened to him and I am now relieved because I feel myself floating and I may not know where I am going, but it is so much more liberating than being grounded and weighed down because that is what gravity does and demands.

It became reinforced by default when I became a journalist in 2005 for a year. I realized that real events and that reality in general, could be parsed for endless, remarkable stories but that to be a beat reporter merely "reporting" that news would be to murder writing merely by other means. Yes, we all need the news with our morning coffee (perhaps - I am sure many, many people prefer a good book, a gander with their dog, a quiet moment with their cat or a stroll in the garden with their coffee in the morning), but the distillation of complex human experience into an anorexic list of facts and statistics about geography, event and numbers dead - the sense of impending doom - is to rob that event and experience of its very profundity even as the promise is made to emphasize its significance and severity by calling it the "news".

So I left and by force of habit, I returned to research. But this time, it was different. In 2007, I had to do field research in Cambodia. I had obligations and deadlines, but not of the PhD bureaucracy variety. It was a short stint and there was wiggle room. I used this time to parse reality and to be in the spaces I went to. I listened to stories. I watched PhD candidates around me filter stories through layers. They would sign off forms; gather data; try to inconspicuously ply survivors of genocide for data and sit them for meals at public forums about international justice, mainly to cajole them to give interviews - more data!

It wasn't that I was on a moral high ground; that being a writer is somehow holy (it really is not and I have met novelists who sound parasitic, the way they suck up cultures, energies and other people's lives and stories for their plots and next novels). It's not even that I wanted to avoid working within a system (academia) that is all about hierarchies and conferring legitimacy (one might say the literary word is very much the same). It's just that I heard the stories differently than my academic PhD candidate peers did; it's that I wanted to be a portal for those stories and a teller of tales. I did not want to experience what I had seen happen to so many of my friends: their relationship to language had (d)evolved so that they used it to conceal rather than reveal. I suspect that high theory and complex, dense sentence structures are lauded as a kind of high art; a kind of uncrackable code that only the initiated had a right to tackle and only the very few and very best could even understand.

But the danger is in seeing obscurity pass itself off for brilliance; what worries me the most is that they no longer worried about not being understood other than by their peers, mentors and advisors. And on the few occasions that they did try to be understood by us mere mortals, it simply did not work. It's like they had lost the ability to speak simply and to interact in an intimate way with others through language - that this wonderful facility we had, to connect with others intensely through words, had simply withered from lack of use.

I never want to experience that death.

So here I am and what I have finally realized is that I do hope to be able to tell stories about the things happening around me.

But here is the other strange thing that is happening - fiction is invading my innards. I mean the seeds of ideas are being scattered by some unseen force. It's a bit of a tease because I don't get much by way of a really substantial, chunky story. I get the hints of something delectable. It happens at the most unexpected moments too - when I am lying in bed and trying to sleep (tough); when I am swimming and staring at the trees all around. When I am writing something else altogether (write me instead! it teases).

I think I am supposed to do something with these starters, these seeds...these beginnings and possible trajectories.

I am not yet sure what and I am not yet sure I know how.

That will be for another letter. This one ought to have been sent weeks ago. And now I am struggling just to remember how I felt when I began it. Letters are like a meditation session: there's no such thing as "I think I'll take a break for a bit and come back to it". It doesn't work because it's a kind of internal conversation with the other person.

If I sound a bit odd somewhere in the final third of this letter, this is the reason why.

You asked about Neil Gaiman - I have been reading the stories in Smoke & Mirrors. There's something so simple about them that they make me think "I could have written that", which of course is deceptive and is a bullshit thought (if you could, you would have - no other way to put it). I like that immediacy though. I get the sense American Gods is supposed to be the thing to read though...he refers to it plenty on his own twitter account.

I've been following the amusing, poignant and sometimes revelatory tweets of Gaiman and his partner Amanda Palmer (formerly of Dresden Dolls). Do you know her? Do you like their music?

Hope you're well - am sure Joyce is keeping you more than sufficiently occupied. New songs?

Take care,
Vinita


No comments:

Post a Comment