Monday, August 22, 2011

Letter to M

Dear M,

This is a long overdue reply, but it wasn't for lack of desire to write. I always think of you as my gut-sister. We don't get to meet often, but I feel that we have these complex relationships with our guts and I fully understand the subterranean realm you (and I) need to exist in, and that sometimes, thank god for e-mail, really. Thank god for the letter that can reach a friend immediately, which you can write in the quiet comfort of your own private space.

I've been well. I have indeed, completely recovered from surgery. I feel like what a pebble, a stone must feel like held back against a rubber band, stretched to the maximum, in a sling-shot. In that moment before being ejected on a trajectory, before taking 'flight', there is such apprehension. There is a feeling that perhaps something terrible is about to happen. Then, when the hand releases and the stone flies - there is the illusion of...well, flight. I'm sure the stone doesn't think 'Well, this is kinetic energy. It will wear off and then I will hit the ground with a powerful thud." The stone probably thinks "I am flying!" It probably even gets to feeling a little cocky. It contemplates other flight paths, other destinations. Ah, if it only knew! And would there be something to landing, hurting, and then just touching the ground and taking in the heat, the light, the rain, being picked up by monkeys, being crawled on by insects; allowing a butterfly a moment of respite when it chooses to land on the stone? Would there be something to just being there?

Surgery and post-op was like being the stone in that sling-shot, just before launching into the skies. You are sure only death and pain await you on the other end, but you brace yourself because apparently, life has got you in a sling-shot.

July and August has felt like the illusion of flight - I am the stone in flight - a little cocky, a little brash, a little over-confident.

Whenever gravity has beckoned me, its long finger calling me and pointing to the ground, I have caught an upstream air current and I've stayed afloat, a-flight. I tell gravity to shove off, because I was in a sling-shot and things could have back-fired. I might have been desperately wounded, a part of me might have chipped off; I might have very quickly descended to nothingness right below. I might have hit something/one, only, the impact might have killed me instead, ripping me apart into many shards, turning me into so much gravel dust, pathetic, formless, just detritus clinging to the grip of someone's shoes.

But I flew. And why should I stop?

The thing is, I am now winded (a ha, what a funny word to use, given the image being painted here). Gravity doesn't even have to beckon. It's looking up at me and it's got a bit of a pensive look on its face; or is it just compassion? Empathy? It understands, and it knows. I am rapidly descending and then, when I hit the ground and I try to use the force of impact to reach up again, to bounce, to take flight, all I do is return downwards, another part of me impacting with the ground. Gravity can do nothing but watch and wait. It is waiting for me to let go and fall and be free. It is waiting for me to stop hurting myself.

I am there now, several parts of me feeling a little chipped off. I am worse for wear and surprised and upset that flight evaded me. I can't reconcile with merely taking off on a trajectory and seeing that through and settling to the ground. But it seems gravity is. So I have to be with it as well.

I can't see it now, but perhaps having bits of me chipped off means I will take shape into something new; maybe I'll round out; maybe the rough edges will be tempered and maybe I will be gentler to the hand that reaches and touches me; for the ant that climbs and crawls over me and decides I am kind to its tiny feet.

I've been doing so much. But I am winded. My gut is unhappy. Everything in me wants to stop but nothing in me can. I am not sure how to pull these opposing threads together and make them wind and coil together so they realize they are not oppositional entities; that they are forces coming from one energy source and that if they melded, they'd make something far more beautiful than if they fought.

That, my dear, is where I am.

It doesn't answer your question in tangible, literal terms at all. But it most definitely is more true to my current state of mind. I am rather tired of living in the state that is my mind. I am keen to migrate to the state that is my Soul.

Do you know how one might do that?

With love,
Vinita

Thursday, July 28, 2011

Dear Mother

Dear Mother,                                                                                                 25 July 2011

This morning, struck by despair, I ran through a mental list of names of people I could call. This is no ordinary morning – it is the umpteenth layer on an ever-growing, complex picture composed of tiny bursts of realization. I had been awoken in the early hours, still shrouded in darkness, by sharp claps of thunder. This continued for at least an hour before the steady hiss of rain took over and the treble-tone of the initial thunder turned into a deep, rumbling baritone – a quietly angry sky whose rage had been quelled by opening up and letting go. The deluge.

At about that time, I also got severe cramps. Half-asleep and half-awake, I curled up, straightened out, placed a pillow between my knees, slept on my side, slept on my back and furrowed my brows and let out murmurs. Instead of staying with the thought “I am getting my period”, my thoughts drifted to “if this is a regular monthly sensation, how will labour pains feel? Will it be this pain, magnified at least 20 times? Is there a way to approximate the pain? How would I cope?”

I went to a place that I have been going to a great deal off-late. It is a place called “babies” and I frequently visit it now. I think about it and feel it and play with the idea in my mind and increasingly, long to feel it in my body as sensations, rather than as an intellectual thought in my head.

I woke up to work and to other people’s problems. I felt myself sinking and I felt pain. The pain is real. It is there in my body now. How I sit with it, how I experience it, is in my hands. But the sinking sensation is not real at all. It is someone else’s emotions. I have been here before.  I have suffered because of other people’s emotions. I have been in the hell that they have created and I have entered their hell of my own volition. Other people’s privation have often become my own. No one forced me to go there, but once inside, I held them entirely responsible for how I suffered. People will compel you into their pain because that is the last resort to gain attention, when civility has failed. To see this is wisdom. To resent them for it and to participate in the perpetuation of that pain is often the condition of existence, is it not Mother? It is the condition we ought to move away from. But it is difficult.

This is how my morning began. It began this way because my night (1am, to be precise) had ended with this person’s pain as well. This person had managed to envelope me in pain, bracketing me on either end so that the night’s anxiety had merely transformed into something less dark in the early hours of the day, though no less sinister and formidable.

I went through names.

I came up with little. I had caveats or a nota bene beside this or that name. He’s working. She just broke up with her boyfriend; I hardly know her; I work with them; these people are younger than me.
Then I called you. I hesitated first because your mornings can be busy. But I am your daughter and I felt the world would stop for you, if I needed you. I believed that and I called. And your world did stop.

You stood still for me and you came to me, a voice through the line. I felt I could speak the unspeakable – hatred, frustration, the deepest cynicism I keep buried and guard safely inside because to unleash that beast would be to ruin the landscape of my existence, like so much detritus and death after a war. But I articulated it all with you and you did not contradict me. You didn’t encourage my belligerence and rage either. You merely understood. Merely – merely, in that that is precisely what you did. You focused. I wanted to fall off the edge and go tumbling down. You assured that something below would break my fall – you allowed me the space to experience this deep distress and rage. But you assured that I would not be broken by it. You gave me safety.

I have stood naked before you, even in my adulthood. I have stood naked with a scar that sent such searing pain through my innards, I was not sure I could stand up straight. When I caved, naked and alone, you were there for me. You rubbed my back, you propped me up. You clothed me and you caressed me as only a mother can, and you gave me your strength, of which you seem to have an endless reserve. You took my pain and you seemed to send it out into another place, another dimension, away from here.

We have fought so much. We have fought over the most intimate discoveries of my adult life – love, sex and marriage. I have loathed you for that interference and we have the collective memory, faint though it is, of times when we separated and when we thought we might not mend the rift or bridge the divide. But we chose a kind of amnesia and we chose to remember that time in a didactic manner – a collective lesson that endowed us both with understanding and wisdom. We became novice pedagogues. This is how we survived it. 

It has been hard for us because we are so different, you and I. Your childhood memories in villages and small towns – a life as a young, naive adult whose parents made all of the important decisions for her. My childhood spent in several countries and cities – a hybridized identity and an early understanding of the existential dilemma that arises when you have to decide for yourself who you are. You live for family alone, having sacrificed your sense of self for it. I seem to live for myself alone, and at times in pursuit of grandeur that should follow on from an altruistic existence in the public domain, grandeur that lures me and promises me bliss and immortality.

And yet, this morning, when someone else’s pain threatened to subsume me, it is you I turned to.
But it is not just that.

When I am finally ready to enter the immense, complex, beautiful, somewhat daunting landscape of having a child, it is you I turn to. Yes, I go to my peers, the young mothers, to ask them what it is like. They are liable to remember better what it is like. But they have not yet lived with it like you have and here is this wondrous circularity – what you have done, what you have lived with and attempted to understand is a who and that who is me. Here I am and here we are together, each of us an experience the other has lived with and continues to understand, to grow with, to love and support, to be perplexed by.

And with this too, you listen Mother. You don’t do anything more or less. You have put aside prasadam, a sort of talisman for me, gleaned from the rituals performed for Ambal Goddess, to make the experience of childbirth calm, beautiful, meaningful – a safe experience. You never mentioned it to me. You merely kept it and waited. 

Today you told me about this talisman and you said you would give it to me. I am waiting to receive it Mother because I am finally ready to hold something like that in my hands to feel its meaning and its power.

I told you I had not stopped believing in your god; but that I had stopped believing in prayer and ritual being performed merely for the sake of it – as a cultural indicator and marker of identity, than as a thing felt deep inside one’s soul. I did not want to rob ritual and prayer of that power, by doing it for the sake of doing it. I hope never to live life merely going through the motions.

You struggled to understand this, but you let it go.

Today I told you, pray for me and before you could interrupt, I told you that for the first time in years, I had something I wanted to pray for. It is not that I have found god. It’s that for the first time I see myself as part of something greater and I wish to connect with that, if I am going to do something like have a child with the man I love. Because you see, when I spoke to you about that as-yet unborn, non-existent child, I felt it come into existence as a thought and I felt the power of that thought. I had felt the power of a negating thought (I do not want this) and I knew its opposite. In that moment, I felt something akin to the completion of a circle. I felt myself talking to you, my Mother, about the child I wished to have. The past, the present and the future suddenly occupied the same space-time continuum – I felt us three together and I felt then, that I was part of something larger and that, surely, merits a prayer, an acknowledgement of the greatness of this thing we call life.

I had awoken in the morning enveloped and bracketed by someone’s pain.

As I spoke to you, I tried to shed this and felt myself being embraced by a different and new energy – yours and that of the child I long to have. I felt the two of you surround me and embrace me. I felt both of you assure me that there is joy in this and there is joy in the unknown and that you’d both be there for me, as I promise you both I will be there too – to read and write you both stories; to share the travails of my life. And we all will quell each other’s rage, foster love and open up a vast world of our own making where each of us can safely explore who we are and who we wish to become. We will, I hope, embrace our becoming.

I wept Mother and I tried to hide it from you, not from embarrassment but for want of breath to speak the words that were rushing out of me – a tidal wave of emotion, chaotic and confused. You heard the knot in my chest but you did not ask about it. We share this silence in the deluge of speech and that is the place of understanding. We reside there too, just as we reside in speech and stories. But I know I can break and be silent with you. I know I can break and weep outwardly or inwardly and that you will hear it through the roar of my words. 

We don’t agree about what food to eat; we may not agree about what to wear and we may not even agree about what a woman ought to do with her life and what constitutes a sense of purpose in a woman’s life. We occupy different realms when it comes to these matters, these decisions and milestones that make up the chapters of one’s storybook.

We’ve made mistakes Mother, you and I (your daughter).
We have fought fiercely.
We have used forceful words; unkind, cruel words.
We’ve abandoned each other. 

We have come to that dark place where we thought we could live without each other because we each valued such oppositional things that our universes seemed, at that moment, to be incommensurate.
But now I know you see the quietude of my soul through the roar of my bodily self.

I hope Mother, I can give him/her what you’ve given me, when I become a Mother like you.

Monday, July 11, 2011

Letter to K

Dear K,

Will I remember last week as that transitional phase (2 weeks before my birthday) when I allowed myself to form and shape a thought that I have held at bay, condemned, questioned, critiqued, deconstructed and generally disavowed with every bit of intellectual energy, logic and emotion within me?

If I do, then I will have you to thank for it, though it still feels a little dubious and I am not sure (yet) if I want to thank you.

It is not about what I will do. It is not yet about future decisions. It is so very much about the present. I keep moving forwards in such a hurry - how will it be 5, 10, 20 years from now; what will it mean; where will I be in this world and will it be the right place to be and who am I in all of this?

And then, you called from the other end of the world - British Columbia to Singapore. It was about midnight for you and about 3pm for me and we spoke for nearly 3 hours. When we finished, you were making breakfast for your husband as he got ready for an early shift and I made myself a coffee that I had with a piece of brownie. I sat and stared at the trees outside, I think. I sat and just didn't think. I felt like a different person.

I felt like a new landscape inside me that I had prevented myself from ever entering, had opened up. Permits have been issued. The roads have been paved; the path has been cleared. I am not packing my bags to head there and settle down just yet. That is a big step for someone who pretended that part of my inner world didn't even exist. I am still getting used to the idea that this world inside is larger than I had initially imagined. If that knowledge is hidden even from me, can you imagine what else there is I don't know about myself?

Can you live in a state of exile if you've never even been to a place? Can thinking about that place/space relentlessly constitute a kind of "visit", after which one day, you tell yourself you will not think of it anymore and that is it - exile.

I was looking at others, expecting to feel like them. I was looking for signs. Even as the logic-oriented part of my brain told me "ah but every experience is liable to be slightly different; not unique per se, but variations on a theme", I still looked for...semblance, sameness, confluence.

Basically, if I didn't feel like her or her or her, then I was not feeling it. I was not prepared for the possibility that my rendering, my version of this feeling, would be this feeling. This is it! This is how I am dealing with it; this is what is happening inside me. This is who I am right now (perhaps and not totally).

You asked me how I was imagining it because I had all the freedom to imagine it as I desired it. Kate Bush, Kristin Hersh, Anne Fadiman all popped into my mind. Musicians and writers.

I thought about this first - the thrill of telling stories and playing songs! Can you imagine that? Even before language is possible, I would be able to tell stories to him/her. And then I'd have a long stretch of my life to tell stories before s/he began writing his/her own stories.

That thought filled me with joy and for a moment, the thousand weights I had used to weigh the balloon down were slashed off and the balloon seemed to lift off the ground.

Oh but there are fears.

Like I said, I am not ready for the journey there - yet. I know that I can go there and I know how to get there, I think. I have some inkling. This is already so new. I must sit with it a while, play with the images in my mind; roll it around in my mouth to try and taste it; play the sounds inside to hear it. I have to just be with this for a while. Then I think I will know.

Today, someone reminded me (while I held her baby and we played in the water) that feeling grounded and happy in yourself is an essential prerequisite. The absence of joy will be felt by everyone.

So - I am making room for joy and I am asking fear to take leave of my being.

What will I remember of our conversation when I enter that landscape, I wonder? I will at least remember to thank you.

Thank you.

Love,
Vinita

Letter to G - Literary / Narrative Journalism

Dear G,

I said I'd write soon and then fell into a listless spell - the kind in which you get a fair bit of work done and all of it is more or less inspired and interesting, but nothing compared to that delicious internal universe you reside in with your ideas, your words and the creative creatures you will make out of them.

So, I've not been able, nor willing, to write.

I did read something that reminded me of why I write and what kind of writing, ultimately, I sort of fantasize about being able to do really well. The birth of this kind of writing is captured here in the New York Magazine by one of its great proponents, Tom Wolfe. I'm talking about literary journalism. Trust me to fantasize about the one kind of writing that is improbable and impossible in an authoritarian city-state in which there is no free press. But perhaps that is what makes it all the more delectable - ah pursuit of the impossible.

This love affair began a while ago though. I think hints of it began when I was in university, actually. When I was able to take literary liberties (narrative structures that are interesting; subtle flourishes) in essays about cinema, literature or even cultural theory and philosophy, I first sensed it. But academic writing nearly killed it as much as I enjoyed theory and theorizing. Having to stop and substantiate, footnote, supplement, provide citations and references to other instances in which your idea was raised, expressed and written about at another time, foreshadowing the development of said idea etc.etc. etc. ad nauseum made me realize academic writing was intensely crippling. It felt like wearing armour, a cumbersome, heavy and movement-restriction suit to lumber about on the surface of the moon, when really all you want to do is fly off the surface and defy gravity.

I knew I'd never do a PhD once I was reminded by M that the only thing drawing me to it was a love of philosophy, theory and primarily, a love of writing. And so one day, he put it simply. He said, "If you love writing, then write! Don't do a PhD. It will ruin and curtail that ability and that freedom." I listened to him and I am now relieved because I feel myself floating and I may not know where I am going, but it is so much more liberating than being grounded and weighed down because that is what gravity does and demands.

It became reinforced by default when I became a journalist in 2005 for a year. I realized that real events and that reality in general, could be parsed for endless, remarkable stories but that to be a beat reporter merely "reporting" that news would be to murder writing merely by other means. Yes, we all need the news with our morning coffee (perhaps - I am sure many, many people prefer a good book, a gander with their dog, a quiet moment with their cat or a stroll in the garden with their coffee in the morning), but the distillation of complex human experience into an anorexic list of facts and statistics about geography, event and numbers dead - the sense of impending doom - is to rob that event and experience of its very profundity even as the promise is made to emphasize its significance and severity by calling it the "news".

So I left and by force of habit, I returned to research. But this time, it was different. In 2007, I had to do field research in Cambodia. I had obligations and deadlines, but not of the PhD bureaucracy variety. It was a short stint and there was wiggle room. I used this time to parse reality and to be in the spaces I went to. I listened to stories. I watched PhD candidates around me filter stories through layers. They would sign off forms; gather data; try to inconspicuously ply survivors of genocide for data and sit them for meals at public forums about international justice, mainly to cajole them to give interviews - more data!

It wasn't that I was on a moral high ground; that being a writer is somehow holy (it really is not and I have met novelists who sound parasitic, the way they suck up cultures, energies and other people's lives and stories for their plots and next novels). It's not even that I wanted to avoid working within a system (academia) that is all about hierarchies and conferring legitimacy (one might say the literary word is very much the same). It's just that I heard the stories differently than my academic PhD candidate peers did; it's that I wanted to be a portal for those stories and a teller of tales. I did not want to experience what I had seen happen to so many of my friends: their relationship to language had (d)evolved so that they used it to conceal rather than reveal. I suspect that high theory and complex, dense sentence structures are lauded as a kind of high art; a kind of uncrackable code that only the initiated had a right to tackle and only the very few and very best could even understand.

But the danger is in seeing obscurity pass itself off for brilliance; what worries me the most is that they no longer worried about not being understood other than by their peers, mentors and advisors. And on the few occasions that they did try to be understood by us mere mortals, it simply did not work. It's like they had lost the ability to speak simply and to interact in an intimate way with others through language - that this wonderful facility we had, to connect with others intensely through words, had simply withered from lack of use.

I never want to experience that death.

So here I am and what I have finally realized is that I do hope to be able to tell stories about the things happening around me.

But here is the other strange thing that is happening - fiction is invading my innards. I mean the seeds of ideas are being scattered by some unseen force. It's a bit of a tease because I don't get much by way of a really substantial, chunky story. I get the hints of something delectable. It happens at the most unexpected moments too - when I am lying in bed and trying to sleep (tough); when I am swimming and staring at the trees all around. When I am writing something else altogether (write me instead! it teases).

I think I am supposed to do something with these starters, these seeds...these beginnings and possible trajectories.

I am not yet sure what and I am not yet sure I know how.

That will be for another letter. This one ought to have been sent weeks ago. And now I am struggling just to remember how I felt when I began it. Letters are like a meditation session: there's no such thing as "I think I'll take a break for a bit and come back to it". It doesn't work because it's a kind of internal conversation with the other person.

If I sound a bit odd somewhere in the final third of this letter, this is the reason why.

You asked about Neil Gaiman - I have been reading the stories in Smoke & Mirrors. There's something so simple about them that they make me think "I could have written that", which of course is deceptive and is a bullshit thought (if you could, you would have - no other way to put it). I like that immediacy though. I get the sense American Gods is supposed to be the thing to read though...he refers to it plenty on his own twitter account.

I've been following the amusing, poignant and sometimes revelatory tweets of Gaiman and his partner Amanda Palmer (formerly of Dresden Dolls). Do you know her? Do you like their music?

Hope you're well - am sure Joyce is keeping you more than sufficiently occupied. New songs?

Take care,
Vinita


Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Letter to V

Dear V,

What an extraordinary three hours we had yesterday! M and I started our morning talking about self-actualization over coffee. As far as mornings go, it was a great one.

We had a powerful thunderstorm out here last night - it started around midnight. The lightning flashes were brighter than staring straight at the sun with one's naked eye. I had my eyes closed, the room was dark, and still, the flash hit my cornea and I felt my interior visual landscape light up - bright and white. Every time I had a thought about my life and where I wanted it to go, there would be another bright electric flash. It seemed poetic and made me smile (even though I generally hide my head under the covers when there is lightning). There were deep rumblings and then a steady rain and this morning, the trees are wet with due, rainwater and everything is cool, quiet and peaceful.

Many thoughts surfaced after our conversation yesterday. I've been thinking a lot about creativity, about the role of the writer, and about happiness.

As a writer, as someone who strongly desires to embody what this means (to write, to send words out into the world, to hear words inside and bring them to life) I feel that I have to make room for what one of my favourite musical duos of the past, Lamb, referred to in a song as "Darkness & Wonder". The song is worth citing here in its entirety:

I couldn't see darkness until now
Only light!
(though sometimes the shadows flickered across my view)
Light!

But darkness, this cold emptiness,
Somehow passed me by
Like a charmed thing I sailed
Slipping through its fingers

Blessed until now
Blessed until now

Only now, only now, only now

And I'm beyond recognition
Gone to some small space in silent stillness
Yet something beats anew

Somewhere

I'm waiting to be reborn

Only this time, only this time, only this time
Born in darkness
None can dim my light
None. Can. Dim. My. Light.

I feel that being able to articulate darkness is as important as being able to make room for light and I usually do not seem them as a dichotomy. We talked about this yesterday - I said to you that my life and the thoughts and feelings that animate it, seem to me to be connected in a very large, intricate web. Think of those gargantuan, elaborate webs that spiders painstakingly build over several weeks. It is virtually a world. So what happens over at this end - what is captured in the sticky, delicate thread over here, may have nothing to do with the opposite end of the web. But the resonance is felt. It's like circuits and roads in the electrical / physical world. Everything eventually impacts on everything else.

So when I think of "darkness & wonder", I think of them as co-existing and animating my being and my becoming. As a writer, I feel I have to speak honestly to all of it - every shade of emotion.

It is not about truth-telling (we all have our truths and we all pursue versions of the thing). It is about authenticity, as you said.

Now, happiness.

This morning, M and I wondered this: if self-actualization seems to make people happy, why do so few people do it?

Some of it appears to be about habit and oddly enough, legacy. I looked up the word (so often we use words, never fully exploring their meaning, the nuances).

It's largely a word used in legal parlance, but broadly, it is defined as:
"anything handed down from the past, as from an ancestor or predecessor".

Our perceptions, our habits, our way of being in the world are our legacy - it is the stuff we get handed down by our parents and our predecessors. It's how we're raised and how we're taught to regard the world and our place in it. We "inherit" values, a sense of ethics, a sense of what is good and right, no doubt. But like I said, emotional baggage is precisely that: it's a suitcase full of stuff. Things are not carefully cordoned off or partitioned. Things bleed into each other when they share space together. So we also inherit the fears, limitations and an understanding of threats in the world, that our parents grew up with (which no doubt, they inherited and so it goes). Some of this protects us and enables us to realize ourselves in the world, within carefully delineated limits and that is fine - if we are happy doing this. Some of this limits us and prevents us from seeing that what we think is inherent to who we are is just legacy - it is what we've learned, what we've imbibed, what's we've inherited. It can be - like building blocks - taken apart and we can make new things with it. It may even be possible to discard some of the pieces, or add news ones, if what you want to make can no longer be created using the pieces handed to you.

And here's another interesting bit; in IT parlance, "legacy" has a meaning too:

"of or pertaining to old or outdated computer hardware, software, or data that, while still functional, does not work well with up-to-date systems".


I found this incredibly striking (very often, I find science and IT language provide useful metaphors for other aspects of living and life).

This is what stood out: it's old data that is still functional, but does not work well with up-to-date systems. We're not talking about something that is dead, defunct, archaic and beyond use. We're talking about something that can still function. I keep repeating this because it just keeps capturing my attention.

How many of us are operating with legacies, with entire ways of being (and becoming) that more or less function, but which are out of step with who we are or with potential forms of expression in general?

That's one question, one idea that I am sitting with right now.

The second goes back to my initial question - if self-actualization is about the process of taking apart those foundational pieces and who knows, changing the very materials that compose the ever-evolving structure (i.e. let's dispense with Lego pieces and let's work with clay; let's try some plasticine and play-dough, or maybe metal and copper wire, or cloth and organic material), and if that process can be intensely liberating, why do more or us not do it?

I don't have an answer but (as we discussed yesterday) looking to one's experience seems a good place to start contemplating the possible responses. And what I come up with is this: it's just too damn hard and it's a lot of work.

This sounds grossly over-simplified. But if you take the simple example of "jobs" and work in general, it's illustrative. I hear plenty of people groan and whine about their bosses and their places of work. I see them quit and then re-enter another work environment where the same patterns are perpetuated. I do not blame these people. Bills have to be paid and life throws responsibilities our way, sometimes unanticipated, and taking stock or taking time to do what we like to do is defined as a luxury. Like many things in life, I think this is only partly true. People say being self-employed is difficult because you are your own disciplinarian; you have to create your own structure and set your own targets and while bosses and hierarchies are loathsome, it's just easier than having to be your own boss.

Part of the process of stopping and taking stock, is about looking at what animates and populates your world, your life, and making a concerted effort to basically re-build something different. Sometimes it may even involve accepting that you will come up empty 6 months, 1 year, 2 years and even 5 years down the road. You may have to keep on tweaking, fine-tuning, re-configuring, re-piecing the parts. I get the sense that very few people want to do that kind of work. The irony for me is that people will spend 15 hours per day working for (and on) something they do not care about, nor even believe in; they may even loathe it a bit. But they will do it. But if asked to pause, take stock and step out of that life to work on self-actualization, they will not do it because it's basically too much work.

What do we work for? Who do we work for?

Again, how we work is the legacy of hundreds of years of a very particular idea of work and productivity handed down to us by our parents, grandparents and their ancestors. Self-actualization has been submerged and subsumed under a larger mandate and that broader, general definition of work. To realize oneself, one realizes what institutions, structures, families and generally, what others define and pass down to you. To self-actualize is to actualize what these external entities tell us to do.


So if that is our inheritance, imagine being told that even how we understand self-actualization can be changed; imagine being told you can participate in the creation of your own life; imagine being told you already are an active participant in that life. You occupy the centre of it and you drive it and embody it and breathe life into it.

That is a lot to process; it is too much damn work. It is easier to maintain the status quo and to be what others have defined is the right type of person to be.

What I see, when I see parents (mine, other people's but not everyone by any stretch) is this disorientation in the face of people who are keenly engaged in the process of self-actualizing. First, it doesn't seem possible (nobody told them it was); second, it turns the mirror on them and they wonder who they are (they are not sure they know). Third (for the more sensitive) it is as though their legacy, the inheritance they have handed down, is being rejected, or given back to them. They are not always able to differentiate between that sense of rejection, and the notion that people, things and life changes.

To me, this crisis is a deeply productive process (productive, not in the sense of how the word is defined by our work-obsessed culture as producing useful stuff, but as generative and creative power). It is a crisis laden with possibilities for renewal. Of course, you have to stick around after what feels like a storm, to pick through what looks like wreckage. But ah there is such beauty in the chaos. Such discovery.

Happiness and self-actualization to me, isn't a thing to be found and mastered and held onto. It is not a book I can buy and put on my shelf. It is not the yoga routine in the mornings; it is not the herbal tea I drink everyday that promises to heal me, or any of the things we do that promise us a moment of contentment. It isn't even in the perfect job I chose to undertake, which gives me hours of endless joy. Happiness is this chaotic, creative and unpredictable process. It will be messy. But we wake up to possibilities and in that plurality, there is real power (again, not power as a thing to acquired and used for domination, but a pure energy that animates our innards).

If we can be told that what has been handed to us as truths, are in fact legacies - carefully crafted ways of being in the world defined by others at a different time and place - we are presented with the opportunity to examine our inheritance and to choose what we wish to keep, discard and change. If we are told that we too will leave something behind in this world but that we can choose what that is (a child; a movement; a way of thinking and being in the world; a philosophy; an idea; a work of art; companionship offered in moments of desolation and alienation), then once again, we have the opportunity to realize that each of these ways are precisely that: a way. Not "the only way".

Our worlds will be shaken to the core. But after the storm, such opportunity to re-build.

Thank you for yesterday - for allowing me to sit with this and think it through; for inspiring me to articulate it.

With love,
Vinita

Monday, June 6, 2011

Letter to W

Dear W,

The story was written in a spirit of jest - a sort of heroic fuck-you to pain. It skirted around the edge of that perpetually present emotional abyss, what I've now come to call the dark matter at the centre of my galaxy threatening to suck up all the pretty stars I make that shine and populate my small end of the universe.
I didn't think I would slip in, or that, tipping over the edge, I'd get that drunken swaying sensation, the vertigo worse than jumping off the edge of a building because there is no count-down to impact. Just perpetual falling.
I lost my grip last night - sort of one foot over the edge, a trip, skidding off and then holding on with my arms until I got hauled up.
It happened because it was night and I could no longer see the emerald-green splendour outside my window, or even the adult Macaque monkeys that have taken to strolling along our window planters everyday, peeking in seriously to survey the scene, figure out what can be grabbed (a mango, an apple, a banana: more than one has figured out how to get to our apartments out back).
My mother left after what has been a ten-day period of dedicated 24/7 care-taking - fresh, home-cooked meals everyday, tea in the morning, coffee in the afternoon, the occasional conversation, the sharing of a thought after reading this or that book.
I was glad she was getting a break and when we dropped her off at the bus-stop to go home, I was still fine, though I felt a pang - the sight of my mother, her increasingly greying hair and her confident wave good bye only made me think of how fragile she (and I?) was.
I got home and the emptiness hit - vast nothingness.
Neil de Grasse Tyson, the astrophysicist, wrote on his twitter page that astronomers and physicists are not afraid of the dark because that is what enables them to turn their telescopes to the skies and find the million stars unseen to the naked eye. It is so crowded out there. It is a carnival.
Too bad I am not an astrophysicist. All I saw was nothing. The absence of what was, rather than the emergence of what was not.
And then I just wailed like a baby. All the courage, the stoicism of the past few weeks, few months, came to a stop, as though I'd subscribed to a limited resource, a trial-run of life-with-guts. I ran out and came up empty. It hadn't stuck. It hadn't rubbed off.
I cannot go through this again. But I am 32. So the statistical probability of experiencing pain, degeneration and illness is somewhat high. This is not because I am a pessimist or a hypochondriac or psychosomatic. It's just how it goes. Add to that the fact that the gene pool I've emerged from isn't the most resilient sample, and the probability increases by slightly more.
Does courage come in different colours? Are there varieties like flora that one can hot-house, grow, breed?
The kind I grew these past few months, it's a good variety - it's hardy. It's a little masculine. It has the hint of anger and defiance, but very little so that the overall impact is a calm, gutsy exterior.
But I've no idea if it will do the trick when the next big thing hits. Bad luck bad luck! Everyone says "stop saying when." Don't invite it, they say. I am not. I am just prepared. But I might need something hardier. Less anger and defiance and a bit more humour maybe. The story was good. I need a bit more of where that came from.
But really it boils down to a simple equation. Life can be distilled to a mathematical pattern  and even if I find the idea repulsive, I do see its essence as calculable:
I am afraid of pain. I need people to support me through pain. Right now, those people are elderly parents and friends. The latter are great (they're my age and hopefully none of them are planning early exits), the former are 60 years old and above.
There will come a time when the people who have spent their entire lives with me (my parents) will no longer hold my hand or wipe my vomit and prop me up when I am in some kind of physiological hell. There is a good chance I might be the one doing it for them (and I am ready for that - for the preservation of dignity in the midst of things that threaten to rob us of it).

And then what happens? Who will be there when I am alone?

Yes, my husband. I haven't forgotten him. But two don't make a community.

You see, when you're well, being alone is sexy - you can give it a nice name like "solitude" and you can tell the world in the privacy of your cocoon that you are in a state of "solitary bliss".

When you're sick, you are just alone. Isolation, loneliness and emptiness are your bedfellows, unless you are so drugged that it makes no difference, in which case, great, but why even equate that to being conscious.

So when my mother waved to me and I gingerly walked back into my apartment, even if my husband was beside me, I just faced that - old age, sickness and death. They were sitting on my fucking couch and asking me to make them hot cocoa and I realized I'd left the door unlocked and let the bastards in.

So how will this play out? Because there is no cheating death and unless I am going to make about 3 babies in the next 3 years, this picture is pretty accurate.

Should I talk to them? To Old Age, Sickness and Death, I mean. Maybe this calls for coffee with whiskey in it? I mean, instead of inching backwards away from them and falling into my own dark matter hole, maybe if I sat with them and talked, we'd work something out?

You have a kid - do you think he'll be there for you when those three come for a visit? I mean, will he act as mediator, negotiator and finally, will he ask them to leave, so he can have some quality time with his mother? You have a son. It must mean something.

I don't want to die alone.

Love,
Vinita